Eco Beauty & Fashion

America’s Best Thrift Shops

brunette sits on gray wall wearing blue shirt, skirt and bootsThrifters, start your engines! The 2014 Shop Drop Challenge is underway, and we’re second-hand shopping our way through a month-long ban on buying new.

Right now, there are more than 500 of us committed to a mall shopping pause this month, representing a savings of $30,000 and 3,000 pounds of textile waste diverted from the landfill. Incredible! Will you please share this post with your friends, so we can double those numbers? Thank you!

So where are the best places to pop some tags? Here are a few, IMHO.


Unlike eBay, which can be hard to navigate, I-Ella makes it easy to buy, borrow or swap clothes. Sort by designer, trends, size or real women’s closets—my closet was featured a few years back—then click on an item you like and a popup tells you the retail price and what the owner wants in exchange. Plus, a percentage of proceeds benefits the charity of your choice.


With 32 locations across the country—nine in the Bay Area alone—Crossroads dominates the national upscale thrift store market. Crossroads stores are clean and well-merchandised, and you can score designer goods at a fraction of what you’d pay at retail—many still bearing their original tags. One caveat: Crossroads also sells new clothes, so make sure you’re in the pre-worn section.

Where are the best places to pop some tags? Here are a few, IMHO. From online to national to totally unique—if you’re thrift shopping, I’ve got you covered. And I scored you 15% off at the best of the best! BEST (AND ONLY?) SWAP SHOP: GIVE + TAKE

Nestled in an up-and-coming Santa Monica neighborhood, swapping at this store is like sharing a closet with 400 other women who have far better taste than me. You pay a nominal membership fee, bring in your clothes to swap and get their value in the store—all you have to pay is tax! I don’t know of another swap shop like this, do you? Let me know in comments if you’ve found one!

Give + Take now features a consignment section so you can also shop without being a member. But regulars take their membership seriously—you can’t visit the shop for long before someone shopping next to you points out that you’re wearing her old necklace. And because everything is completely returnable—as well as constantly being returned—you can take fashion risks that would never be possible in a regular store. Like the pleather pants I rocked at last year’s Mommy Greenest holiday party, which we held at—you guessed it—Give + Take.


Yes, the Wasteland on Melrose looks like an Anthropologie flagship, but then you have to deal with the cooler-than-thou sales staff, too. At The Closet Trading Company in Santa Monica, you can score everything from Isabel Marant to Missoni, and they specialize in great deals on high end exclusives—think a Helmut Lang sweater for $50—but there are plenty of mid-range labels like Kate Spade and Rebecca Taylor, too. My favorite thing about the store is how they cull the new arrivals into a separate section, especially for us regulars who tend to drop by a few times a month (read: week). And the salespeople are beyond friendly—they’re more like personal shoppers, suggesting styles and accessories, letting you dig through boxes of clothes that haven’t yet hit the shelves and occasionally cranking up tunes for an impromptu dance party.

This is how nice they are: When I told The Closet peeps about this month’s Shop Drop Challenge, they offered a sweet 15% off now through 2.28.14. Just use LABEST15 at checkout when shopping online at or if you’re a walk in, tell them you read about The Closet because of the Mommy Greenest Shop Drop Challenge, and they’ll hook you up!

Why the Shop Drop Challenge? The average American woman spends $60 per month on clothes and dumps six pounds of textile waste into the trash. If we all got together for a shopping pause, we could save nearly $10 billion and one billion pounds of landfill waste. Yes, that’s billion with a b. We’re creating a community of women who have pledged to buy no new clothes or accessories for the 30 days of January and are inspired to thrift and swap their style this month!

Throughout the month, I’ll be posting pictures of my recycled fashion finds here and on our Facebook page, and I’d LOVE to see what you’re wearing, too! Add your photos and descriptions there, Insta them or tweet them to me @RachelLSarnoff and I’ll post ‘em for you. You can also email me at info(at) Remember to hash tag #ShopDropChallenge!


  • Ivy

    Thrifting is the the new word for second hand shopping. While I’m glad it is finally more acceptable, there are still lots of people who would never buy used clothing, Others will only shop at the “cool” places. I have been doing this all my life ( I’m 64) and would love to share a few tips and thoughts.
    I do not buy new clothes because I know I can find it used and save tons of $$. If you are looking for the latest trend, or want a specific garment, thrifting may not be for you. Remember, if you bought it new, wear it, and take it off….it’s used!
    Let’s go!
    Buy natural fibers. They last longer and wear better. I don’t buy anything that needs to go to the dry cleaners because I hate chemicals and don’t want to spend more $$. (Yes, I wash silk blouses and cashmere sweaters in my washer on cold and gentle)
    Buy basic colors. Solids are the first choice. You can mix and match, add scarves and jewelry. (Also at thrift stores) Prints can make an outfit, but limit those .
    Take your time, and get a cart! If you go to Goodwill, Salvation Army or a store that takes donations be prepared to spend some time. They may have them by category ( blouses, sweater, pants, etc) but that’s about it. They may not be sized. Do not be overwhelmed! Go to the section you want and start flipping hangers. See something? Throw it in the cart and keep going. When you get to the end of the rack, look in your cart and weed out.
    Buy it when you see it! It doesn’t matter if it’s the right season, if it’s fab, and a great price, get it or it will be gone.
    Check the label. Not all companies make great clothes, and just because you’ve never heard of them doesn’t mean they’re not well made.
    Check fiber content. ( sometimes inside seam on the left side)
    Check workmanship. Is it well made? What do the seams look like? Are there holes or stains? Look under the arms. Most stores do not accept returns so examine the garment.
    Go often. New items are put out daily. Don’t expect to find exactly what you are looking for the first time.
    Keep a list, written or mental, of what you want if you don’t need it right away,
    Try it on if you can. Obvious reason.
    I could list so many great things I have found, but instead will just mention a few.
    Black silk Eileen Fisher coat with original tags. $5.38.
    Cashmere scarf made in Berkeley $3.49
    shawl collar black velvet vintage coat. $5.38
    Black leather cafe racer motorcycle jacket. $5.38
    Tommy Bahamas silk shirt $3.38.
    Cashmere sweaters ….( lots of them). $3.38.
    (My favorite store is goodwill…..their prices end in .38)

    • Rachel Sarnoff

      Hi Tina! I included Crossroads since it’s national, as well as I-Ella for online national, and then chose the Closet as my local–as well as Give + Take because it’s unique to the whole country, I think! Sorry I couldn’t add more but I hope that you’ll use the comments to share your favorites in your ‘hood. Thanks for reading!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *